Personally I believe The problem is definitely the Guar Gum binder. Guar Gum can act as a laxative (CITATION) and I suspect the quantity they use is far too much for some cats since there won't be any carbs/starch to counteract the laxative effect. From understanding the importance of temperature https://cat-toys91009.wikiparticularization.com/1541001/examine_this_report_on_pets_delight_motor_city